Disciplining Kai – This Mama Needs Help

Yesterday wasn’t the greatest mommy day. I wrote a post about tantrums and touched a little on discipline, but it’s time for me to write another. Kai was at his grandparents this weekend and I’d spent the whole time missing him. When he came back I was really excited to spend time with him, but his granny mentioned he didn’t have his mandatory midday nap. If your child is anything like mine, he becomes a completely different human when he misses his nap. The later it got, the more awkward the time would be for him to nap. He hadn’t eaten, so we were braaing for his lunch and our early dinner and my plan was to put him down after that, a little earlier than his usual bed time. The problem is he ended up becoming overtired and not cooperative. Mistake number 1.

He’s recently started to flail about and try to hit me, instead of just saying ‘no’ when he doesn’t want to do something. Here I am trying to clean him up in his high chair and there’s no other way to get him out, without having some kind of physical contact with him. I started where I usually do with this kind of situation; threaten to take away the toy he was playing with, which I did. When he was still at it, I threatened him with the naughty corner. It’s something we’ve only recently added to the discipline mix. I hadn’t implemented it yet, but Kevin had and it worked well. Kai’s paediatrician suggested it as an extra step before escalating to spanking. She mentioned that Kai’s old enough to understand it, so we agreed to give it a go.

I put him in the naughty corner, explained why he was there and walked away with the plan to fetch him after 2 minutes (one minute per age, as the doctor said). I assumed this is how Kev’s been doing it all this time, so I thought Kai knew the drill. I had to put him back in the corner about three times, before Kev called me over to sugegst staying with Kai in the corner, not just leaving him there. Which I did…or at least, tried to do. He continued turning around, walking out of it, following me or trying to hug me. It was a joke. The last resort we’d previously agreed on if he continued to misbehave, was a spank on the bum. We call it ‘chapa’, Swahili for a ‘whack’. I asked Kai he wants me to chapa him. I’ve done this many times to which he’d usually immediately stop doing whatever it was.

Yesterday he said ‘yeah!’

Shock doesn’t even begin to describe my reaction. I asked him again, just to be clear and it was the same response, so I made good on my promise – twice on the bum. He just looked at me and started giggling. At that point, I really didn’t know what to do. This boy was obviously testing me and not taking me seriously in my own house. I’d threatened in escalation and all the time he was just like ‘what? What are you gonna do?’

I didn’t grow up being smacked. One stern talk from my parents was enough for me. I haven’t been keen to introduce it in my home, so it’s obviously the last resort if he’s not responding to the word. Which, up until yesterday, had worked! So, I did it but I don’t feel good doing it. At this point, I only chapa to snap him out of the behaviour, not to hurt him. I don’t have the heart to do that. Kev was there the whole time, leaving me to handle it, as we’d previously agreed. We get involved if we feel the other person is being unreasonable. What I didn’t want to do is fall into the ‘good cop/bad cop’ habit and ask Kev to take over the disciplining. Anywho, I ended up stopping my efforts, and Kai running off to play with the dogs. I felt strangely, embarrassed and went upstairs for a break.

After finally putting Kai to sleep, I told Kev that I felt rotten about the whole thing. He told me not to be too hard on myself and reassured that I’ll have plenty of opportunities to get it right – haha. He highlighted the things he thought I could do better next time, most of which I agreed.

  • I waited too long to make good on my ‘threats’. Because I didn’t want or expect it to escalate to spanking. I didn’t put him in the naughty corner or chapa him after three strikes, I let it go on for much longer. Kai then saw it as a big fat game.
  • I’m not stern enough when I talk to him. I don’t have a commanding voice and I don’t want to shout at him. I deliberately change my tone and not smile and he used to respond to that well. Ive been trying to be sterner, but this is now proving a challenge.
  • I grew up in a family where showing affection wasn’t the norm, and that affected me. I always knew I’d want to do things differently with my kids so I’m finding myself almost over compensating for that. I don’t think it’s a bad thing, but Kev suspects that Kai’s now not taking me seriously because I’m ‘cuddly Mommy’.

I know that at the end of the day, I’m going to have to figure out what Kai responds best to. It was just one of those days, and I hadn’t had a mommy fail in awhile. I just don’t want this to become the new norm. I’m in a bit of a bind how to move forward and get it under control.

How do/did you discipline your toddler? Have you ever not been able to discipline? What do you do in those situations? Please share mamas!

Photography by Robyn Davie.



  1. Kim
    August 14, 2018 / 9:39 am

    I remember the tantrum stage… I used to simply ignore her.. Walk away from her or over her if she was panned out on the floor..

    Then I did “shock therapy” when she threw a tantrum,
    I dropped to the floor and threw the loudest tantrum next to her. LOL! She never did it again..

    Also When my daughter was in grade R… There was a chair in the corner and it was called the “Growing Good” corner..
    Just like the naughty corner but better.. Encouraging positive change in behavior..

    Work on your stern voice. Practice when he’s not with you… I know it sounds silly.. But try in the car on your way to work.. And be firm.. I know it is very hard to do at first.. But if you don’t start now you are going to have problems with him at a later stage.. When you are disciplining him get down to his eye level and look him in the eye… Eye contact helps to..

    Chapa does work.. To a degree… There after they become oblivious to it cause its over in minutes and only hurts for a second..

    You definitely will find Your way of disciplining him.. Don’t fret..
    Sending you love!

    • Aisha O'Reilly
      September 4, 2018 / 1:05 pm

      Hey Kim, I love the “growing good” chair. I might just steal that! And practicing the stern voice (haha) is also something I might try cos this chappa’ing is weighing on me. Having said that, I honestly haven’t seen anything else be as effective. He just takes everything as a joke. Urgh #momproblems. Thanks for the tips though x

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *